Get Cheeky
Magic Fingers
Magic Fingers
KNOWN FOR: Working wonders with their hands.
MODUS OPERANDI: Peanut butter. Candy crunch. Chocolate. Expert technique.
FAVORITE ALIBI: "I barely touched it."
This thick, chewy Butterfinger-inspired cheeky is loaded with crispy peanut butter crunch before getting wrapped in rich milk chocolate and finished with even more buttery candy crumble. Every bite delivers that unmistakable crisp, flaky crunch with a bakery-sized upgrade.
Once they get their hands on you, it's over.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Ordering & Pickup
Ordering & Pickup
Weekly cheeky drop orders open Monday at 5 PM and close Wednesday at 8 PM unless sold out earlier.
Cheekies are built to serve 2-4 people (if you're feeling generous 😏) and baked fresh in the ordered quantities after each drop closes.
Cheekies cannot be shipped and are available for pickup in Orangevale, CA between these windows:
- Friday 4 PM–7 PM
- Saturday 8 AM–12 PM
Additional pickup details sent after ordering.
NOTE: Pickup windows open and close promptly at the times shown. Because ingredient purchases and the baking schedule are based on pre-orders, any cheekies not picked up by Saturday at 12 PM will be discarded without refund or replacement unless prior arrangements are approved. Thank you for your understanding.
Please contact us directly regarding free delivery within 15 miles of Orangevale on orders of $100.00 or more.
Need help or allergy info? Please see our FAQ page or contact us directly.
Share
