1 2

Get Cheeky

Mixed Signals

Mixed Signals

KNOWN FOR:  Sending all the wrong signals... on purpose.
MODUS OPERANDI:  Lemon. Cheesecake. Strawberry. Emotional confusion.
RELATIONSHIP STATUS:  It's complicated—and that's the best part.

Bright lemon cheesecake sits on a graham cracker crust before meeting a smooth strawberry cream center and a buttery graham crumble finish. Every bite shifts from tart to sweet to creamy without ever picking a side.

Confusing? Maybe. Delicious? Absolutely.

$10.00
$10.00
Sale Sold out

Default is whole. Choose halved or quartered if you want your cheeky pre-sliced.

Ordering & Pickup

Cheekies are built to serve 2-4 people (if you're feeling generous 😏) and baked fresh in small batches based on daily orders.

Cheeky orders open Saturday at 8 AM (PT) and close Thursday at 8 PM unless sold out earlier.

Cheeky order pick up windows depend on the day of order. Please see our Order & Pick Up Schedule in our Fine Print footer section or on our homepage.

Orders containing cheekies are not available for shipping. Please place orders for shipment separately if you are ordering merchandise and cheekies and would like your merchandise shipped.

Apparel and merchandise orders may be placed anytime. Apparel and merchandise orders are available for local pickup or shipping, usually within 5-8 days.

NOTE: Each cheeky order has 2 pick up windows. Because ingredient purchases and the baking schedule are based on pre-orders and quality is important to us, any cheekies not picked up by the close of the second pick up window will be discarded without refund or replacement unless prior arrangements are approved. Thank you for your understanding.

Please contact us directly regarding free delivery within 15 miles of Orangevale on orders of $100.00 or more.

Need help or allergy info? Please see our FAQ page or contact us directly.

View full details